2014
| Number | Name | School |
| 2 | Clark, Nate | Morningside College  |
| 3 | Mamarella, Mason | University of Akron  |
| 4 | Green, Nick | Bradley University  |
| 5 | Goebel, Spencer | Spring Arbor University  |
| 6 | Heberling, Cole | Anderson University  |
| 7 | Clemen, Andrew | South Dakota State University  |
| 8 | Sharrow, Cody | South Dakota State University  |
| 9 | Leverett, Travis | Southwestern Okalhoma State University  |
| 10 | Weber, Carson | Bradley University  |
| 11 | Traglia, Devan | Samford University  |
| 12 | Sturges, Dylan | Oklahoma Christian University  |
| 13 | Baxter, Jake | Oklahoma Christian University |
| 14 | Fisk, Devon | Tiffin University  |
| 15 | Lacayo, Jerry | University of Northern Colorado |
| 16 | Huerta, Luke | Santa Clara University |
| 17 | Anderson, Troy | University of Maryland Eastern Shore  |
| 18 | VanSumeren, Evan | IPFW  |
| 19 | Whitman, Kendall | IPFW  |
| 20 | Shelton, Cody | Samford University  |
| 21 | Sparr, TJ | Howard College  |
| 23 | Jensen, Evan | University of Akron  |
| 24 | Spongeberg, Lance | Morningside College  |
| 25 | Monnig, John | Miami University (Ohio)  |
| 26 | Halgerson, Cole | Morningside College |
| 27 | Kilian, Taran | University of Central Arkansas  |
| 31 | Davies, Shane | Emporia State University  |
| 34 | Beavers, Nick | Southeastern University  |
| 35 | Rhodes, Cory | King CollegeFree Agent – Pittsburgh Pirates |
| Harris, Scott | Buena Vista University27th Round Pick – Phillies |
2013
| Name | School |
| Andrews, Jonathon | Delta State University |
| Baxter, Jake | Rose State College |
| Beavers, Nick | Southeastern University |
| Birdwell, Blaine | Neosho County CC |
| Coshow, Cale | Oklahoma Christian University/Oklahoma University |
| Crowe, Blake | Berea College |
| Detwiler, Kyle | Grand Canyon University |
| Fisher, Nolan | Southeast Missouri State University |
| Fraley, Nate | Dordt College |
| Groskruetz, Cody | Northwestern College |
| Harjo, Jagger | Dodge City CC |
| Johnson, Drew | Southern Illinois U-Edwardsville |
| Leverett, Travis | Southwestern Oklahoma State University |
| Luman, Kevin | Newman University |
| McMillian, Marc | Delta State University |
| Melton, Jeff | Evangel University |
| Mercer, Scott | Cabrillo College |
| Moran, Andrew | Asbury University |
| Murphy, Sam | University of Nebraska-Omaha |
| Pepple, Luke | Bethel College |
| Rideout, Clay | Southeastern University |
| Sturges, Dylan | Oklahoma Christian University |
| Taylor, Ryan | Arkansas Tech University |
| Walker, Nick | Eastern Oklahoma State College |
| Youngman, Dillon | Missouri Southern State |
